Why Indonesia Should Look to Singapore’s Standards
In any high-rise building, the elevator is its heartbeat. Every day, residents depend on lifts to go to work, school, and home. Yet for many apartment residents in Indonesia, lift maintenance is often shrouded in mystery. Breakdowns happen too often, repairs take too long, and residents rarely know where their maintenance fees actually go.
This lack of transparency is not just an inconvenience—it is a safety risk. When residents cannot access maintenance records or understand vendor contracts, accountability disappears. Over time, this creates space for inefficiency, inflated costs, and even corruption in property management.
To understand what transparency should look like, Indonesia can learn a lot from Singapore.
The Singapore Standard: How Transparency Protects Residents
In Singapore, lift safety is treated as a non-negotiable public responsibility. The Building and Construction Authority (BCA) enforces strict regulations under the Building Maintenance and Strata Management Act (BMSMA).
Under this system:
- Every lift must be maintained monthly by a registered and licensed contractor.
- An annual functional test is mandatory to ensure long-term safety.
- Safety certificates must be displayed clearly inside or near the lift.
- Maintenance logs and reports are accessible to the Management Corporation Strata Title (MCST).
This means residents, management councils, and regulators all see the same data. If a lift breaks down frequently, the maintenance contractor can be questioned using real records—not assumptions.
Transparency creates pressure to perform. Contractors know their work is visible, and building managers know they must justify every contract and expense.
The Transparency Gap in Indonesia
Unlike Singapore, many apartment buildings in Indonesia operate with very limited disclosure. In theory, P3SRS (Perhimpunan Pemilik dan Penghuni Satuan Rumah Susun) should represent residents and oversee management. In practice, access to technical and financial data is often restricted.
Common problems include:
- Residents cannot see detailed lift maintenance contracts.
- Technical audit reports are not shared openly.
- Spare-part prices are not benchmarked or justified.
This lack of oversight often leads to serious issues:
- Inflated procurement costs for spare parts.
- Delayed repairs despite high monthly service charges.
- Increased safety risks due to substandard or irregular maintenance.
When residents ask questions, answers are often vague. Without documents, there is no way to prove whether money is being used efficiently or not.
Why Lift Transparency Matters More Than People Think
A lift is not just a machine. It is a daily safety system. Poor maintenance can lead to:
- Sudden stops between floors.
- Door malfunctions that trap passengers.
- Electrical failures and emergency shutdowns.
Every one of these incidents can cause injury, panic, or worse. Transparency is not about paperwork—it is about preventing accidents before they happen.
This is why lift management should be treated as a core part of overall apartment governance, just like fire safety and building structure.
If you want to understand the full picture of how lifts should be managed in apartments, including technical standards, safety, and governance, you can read our main guide here: Complete Guide to Systems, Regulations, Maintenance, and Management in Indonesia
Moving Toward Accountability in Indonesia
For Indonesia to improve, it must adopt what can be called the “Singapore mindset” of transparency. This does not mean copying laws word for word, but copying the principles.
1. Open Tendering
Lift maintenance contracts should be tendered openly. Multiple vendors should compete based on price, capability, and track record. This prevents monopolies and backdoor deals.
2. Digital Maintenance Logs
Every service visit should be logged digitally. Residents and P3SRS members should be able to see:
- Date of last service
- What was repaired
- Which parts were replaced
This creates shared visibility and shared responsibility.
3. Independent Audits
Safety inspections should not rely only on vendors or building managers. Third-party audits reduce conflict of interest and increase trust.
Transparency as an Anti-Corruption Tool
Transparency in lift maintenance may sound like a small issue. But in reality, it reflects a much bigger problem in property management: who controls information controls power.
When residents can see contracts, logs, and audit reports, misuse of funds becomes much harder. Questions can be answered with data, not excuses.
At FPA Indonesia, we believe that transparency in small things—like a functioning lift—is the first step in fighting large-scale corruption in property management. A safe, well-maintained lift is not a luxury. It is a basic right of every apartment resident.
By learning from Singapore’s standards and adapting them locally, Indonesia can build apartment systems that are safer, fairer, and more accountable for everyone.
Â
Â
Â
Â
